Who’s Correct? Stocks or Bonds or Copper or Yen?

There are times when the best market move seems crystal clear.  For a while it was to buy big tech stocks, close your eyes, and hold on.  As we learned last week and yesterday, that of course works until it doesn’t.  Then there are times when the path is much murkier.  That’s what we’re looking at now.

This equity market has been trying its best to digest yesterday’s rout. As I type this, the major tech stocks recovered from an early swoon while small caps led the way.  Although the final outcomes were worse than what we noted around midday yesterday, declining stocks never outpaced advancers at the sort of levels that we see during extreme selloffs.  Even as the S&P 500 (SPX) had its first drop of greater than -2% since December 2022, the ratio of losers to winners was about 4:1.  Today, that ratio has flipped to about 2.5:1 positive, with the Russell 2000 up about +2% and the Russell 1000 Value ETF (VONV) is up about +1% even as its Growth counterpart (VONG) is roughly flat. The rotation continues, even as the ”routation” takes a breather. 

It makes sense that the value and small cap sectors would outperform on a day where we received some positive economic news.  Second quarter GDP came out at 2.8%, well above the 2.0% consensus estimate.  That said, according to my colleague Jose Torres,  inventories almost entirely accounted for the bump.  Perhaps that is why bonds barely flinched, remaining higher (lower yields) after an overnight flight to safety, and why probabilities for rate cuts barely budged.  Data dependent or not, the market has decided that rate cuts are coming, even if that data included a 2.9% quarterly rise in the Core PCE Price index (down from last quarter’s 3.7% but above the 2.7% consensus.  Futures continue to price in a slight probability for a cut next week, the certainty of a cut in September, and a high likelihood for cuts at the two subsequent meetings this year. 

Speaking of bonds, we have seen a remarkable development in recent weeks.  The yield curve, at least as measured by the spread between 2- and 10-year Treasury yields, has been disinverting in a hurry.  The 2-year yields exceeded 10-year yields by about 50 basis points at the start of the month.  As of yesterday, that was down to about 14bp before improving.  That might sound great, but the chart below reminds us that recessions begin after the curve returns to normality. 

Spread between 2-Year and 10-Year Treasury Yields with NBER Recession Start (red) and End (green) Dates

Spread between 2-Year and 10-Year Treasury Yields with NBER Recession Start (red) and End (green) Dates

Source: Bloomberg

Past performance is not indicative of future results

Even if the backward-looking economic numbers show signs of strength, key commodities markets are saying otherwise.  Copper can be a useful tool for gauging global demand, and after a huge run this spring, fueled by AI enthusiasm, that commodity has been steadily given back its recent gains:

COMEX July 2024 Copper Futures, 1-Year Candles

COMEX July 2024 Copper Futures, 1-Year Candles

Source: Interactive Brokers

Past performance is not indicative of future results

Actually, commodities overall have been falling.  One key measure is the Bloomberg Commodities Index (AIGCI on TWS), which has also been dropping.  It’s not just copper:

Bloomberg Commodity Index, 1-Year Line

Bloomberg Commodity Index, 1-Year Line

Source: Interactive Brokers

Past performance is not indicative of future results

These charts bode well for inflation, but not economic activity.  A data-dependent FOMC would likely consider the drops in commodities as part of the overall disinflationary trends, but it is not clear to what extent they might use them as a signal of current economic prospects.

We have been asserting for weeks that next week’s FOMC meeting promises to be quite consequential.  Even if rates don’t change, the rhetoric should offer key clues to the degree to which the group is concerned about economic growth and whether they deem inflationary conditions.  But in the short-term, watch the Japanese Yen for clues.   It is clear that carry traders, those who borrow low-yielding yen to finance higher yielding or riskier investments, are driving the tech market bus right now.  Don’t believe me?  I’ll drop the mic with the following chart:

Past 13 Days, Japanese Yen (15-Minute blue/white candles) vs. September NQ futures (yellow line)

Past 13 Days, Japanese Yen (15-Minute blue/white candles) vs. September NQ futures (yellow line)

Source: Bloomberg

Past performance is not indicative of future results

Related: Options Market Expectations for Tesla and Alphabet